NYPD Pizza Lake Cay

9900 Universal Blvd, Ste 100 Orlando, FL 32819

Hours

Open Monday - Thursday 11 a.m. - 9 p.m.

Friday & Saturday 11 a.m. - 10 p.m.

Closed Sunday

*Holiday hours may vary

407-992-8990

Visit Website

About

NYPD Pizza Lake Cay has served authentic New York-style pizza in the Orlando area for over 20 years.

This pizzeria offers a slice of the Big Apple right in the heart of Florida. Its menu features hand-tossed pizzas, pasta, salads, and delicious appetizers.

NYPD Pizza Lake Cay takes pride in using the freshest ingredients sourced from trusted suppliers, and their commitment to quality and authenticity is evident in every bite.

Vibe

Located in the vibrant Lake Cay area, NYPD Pizza Lake Cay stands out with its inviting exterior and cozy interior, creating a welcoming atmosphere for all its guests.

The restaurant's design pays homage to the classic New York City pizzerias, complete with checkerboard floors, neon signs, and vintage photos of New York City adorning the walls.

The vibe at NYPD Pizza Lake Cay reflects the laid-back Florida lifestyle while connected to the energetic spirit of New York City. The ambiance is perfect for families, couples seeking a casual date spot, or friends gathering for fun and delicious food.

With its impressive menu and inviting ambiance, NYPD Pizza Lake Cay has cemented its status as a beloved Orlando institution.

NYPD Pizza Lake Cay: Menu & Drinks

Dining at NYPD Pizza Lake Cay is where the flavors of New York meet the freshness of Florida. The restaurant's menu is a vibrant canvas of imagination, displaying a stunning array of dishes, making it a dynamic dining destination.

A fan-favorite is the irresistible Manhattan Meat Lovers pizza. A carnivore's dream come true, this specialty pizza is generously topped with pepperoni, homemade Italian sausage, ground beef, and crispy bacon. The abundance of meat is perfectly balanced with a layer of mozzarella, baked to golden perfection on a traditional crunchy, thin crust.

Another crowd-pleaser is the Pasta Puttanesca, a classic Italian dish with a New York twist. This hearty pasta dish is brimming with the robust flavors of olives, capers, garlic, and a hint of anchovy. This deliciousness blends in a tangy tomato sauce and is served with warm, crusty garlic bread.

Quench your thirst at NYPD Pizza Lake Cay with a draft beer or any assorted soft drink.

For a taste of Big Apple pizza on your Orlando getaway, take a journey to NYPD Pizza Lake Cay. You won't be disappointed.

Local Tips

Arrive early to avoid the dinner rush and secure your favorite spot.
Kids Night is Wednesday, and they eat for free!
On Tuesday, buy a specialty pie and get a cheese pizza for free!
Ask for their Veggie Delight pizza if you're a vegetarian.
NYPD Pizza Lake Cay offers a military discount, so bring your ID if you're a service member.
Order online for pick-up to save time and savor it at your Casago rental.

Location

9900 Universal Blvd, Ste 100 Orlando, FL 32819

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the easiest way to get to Orlando?

Orlando is an easy drive-to destination from across the Southeast, with I-95 providing direct access. Orlando is located about 4 hours from Miami, around 7 hours from Atlanta, and only about 1½ hours from Tampa.

For those flying to the area, the Orlando International Airport (MCO) is the biggest and busiest airport in Florida as it serves as a hub for several airlines. While super convenient due to location, be sure to plan for plenty of additional time when flying into or out of Orlando directly. The smaller Orlando Sanford International Airport (SFB) may be another option, mainly serving charter and lower-cost airlines.

Should I rent a car when visiting Orlando?

If you are flying to the Orlando area, renting a car is highly recommended as attractions and neighborhoods are spread out and public transportation is limited. A car is definitely the most efficient way to navigate the area.

Does Casago have pet-friendly vacation rentals in Orlando?

Yes! We proudly offer a range of pet friendly vacation homes, perfect for those traveling with their furry companions. Contact us for more details.

Which beach is closest to Orlando?

Orlando is centrally located in the heart of Florida and not considered a beach destination. However, with Tampa, Jacksonville Beaches, and Miami just an hour to two hours away by car, it’s definitely feasible to combine a beach-day into an Orlando adventure. The most accessible beach option is Cocoa Beach, about an hour east of Orlando. It’s worth noting that Orlando is home to more than 100 lakes, so there are plenty of inviting water activities nearby. This includes several beautiful natural springs.

When is the best time to go to Orlando?

Orlando offers year-round sunshine, which makes it attractive at any time. It has a subtropical climate with hot, humid summers and mild winters. Hurricane season runs from June through November, but direct hits are rare. Higher temps and humidity coincide with the area’s rainy season, which can stretch until early Fall. Orlando’s mild winters make it ideal for snowbirds, while Spring and Fall offer perfect weather.

Are there things to do in Orlando besides theme parks?

Absolutely! Orlando offers plenty of outdoor recreation with its many lakes, world-class golf courses, and beautiful gardens. Orlando has a vibrant cultural and arts scene, as well as numerous unique neighborhoods to explore. Live music, festivals, and sporting events are also key attractions in the area.